As a theme, baseball has lent itself well to the movies. Even when the movies themselves stink (Major League 2, Mr. Baseball, The Babe, et al), the baseball scenes are thrilling (or at least funny). But baseball cards? When was the last time cards factored greatly into the story line of a film? Before IFC's new Diminished Capacity... I'm not sure.

The storyline, in ten seconds or less: Matthew Broderick and Alan Alda team up to sell a rare baseball card, and a high-profile dealer at show tries to swindle them. The dealer character, an obvious caricature of Alan "Mr. Mint" Rosen, is named The Mint-Mint Man (played by Bobby Cannavale, he of Snakes on a Plane fame). So here's why I bring it up at all: the real-life Mr. Mint isn't too happy about the portrayal.


This is interesting for a couple of reasons. First, it's a great big steaming heap of free publicity for Mr. Mint (especially if the film gets national distribution), even if it turns him into more of a caricature than he is now. Second, while withholding personal judgement on the film itself, the log line premise reinforces old stereotypes: we all have cards, and greed (whether our own or that of a corrupt dealer) will ultimately win if and when we try to cash out. And yet, can you picture a movie that paints the baseball card industry in a positive light? If you answered "yes" to that, where does the conflict in your script come from?

And yet there's humor: Try to read TS O'Connell's column on the situation with a straight face. All around the article are banner ads for Rosen's business. How can you take what he writes seriously? What's interesting about this whole thing is not how quickly O'Connell and Sports Collectors Digest jumped to Rosen's defense, but that they acknowledged the situation at all.

This all reminds me of the allegations against Bill Mastro and Mastro Auctions by Michael O'Keeffe and Teri Thompson in their book The Card: Collectors, Con Men, and the True Story of History's Most Desired Baseball Card. Nowhere in SCD or any of its sister publications has there ever been any mention of the book (not even in SCD's end-of-the-year two-part 'Best Books of the Year' compilation). In that instance, O'Keeffe and Thompson weren't just saying that Mastro was a bad guy, but that he trimmed the T206 Honus Wagner, that Professional Sports Authenticators (PSA) knew it was trimmed when they graded it, and that the whole of their subsequent business was built on what basically amounted to a sham. Nor was their account meant to be fictitious.

The difference between these situations is that Mastro never made public his displeasure. If he had, one can only assume that SCD and TS O'Connell would've been at the forefront of the outcry (like Rosen, Mastro Auctions is a large, important advertiser for Sports Collectors Digest).

In comparison to the fraud allegation levied against Mastro–about as serious as you can get in this hobby or any business, for that matter–Mr. Mint's plight seems small-time. And it's not even really about him in the end: it's the hobby that's in the hard spot.


Further Reading
SCD.com Article
TS O'Connell's Take (SCD Infield Dirt)
Honus Wagner card sells for $2.8 million (NY Daily News, 9/6/07)



Dear Friends,

What will you think of when you think of 2007? The year you fell in love? The year you said the hell with it all? Well, for us, I mean me, here at The Baseball Card Blog, 2007 was the year baseball cards crescendoed (if that's a real word). While 2006 saw a explosion in mainstream attention towards the hobby, 2007 was a year of ups and downs, with whatever mainstream attention given focused on the public and private sides of the drawn out Topps sale...

...2007 also saw the publication of Michael O'Keeffe and Teri Thompson's The Card, a telling of the somewhat tawdry history of the former Gretzky/McNall T206 Wagner. Not surprisingly, the book didn't garner much press in hobby publications like Sports Collector's Digest, where Mastro Auctions is a large advertiser. O'Keeffe also achieved my own personal life goal this year when he became an obscure footnote in a text of importance by being quoted in The Mitchell Report...

...2007 saw me sell out to help Topps checklist an under-performing eTopps product, and branch out to Beckett.com for a few weeks there in the summer, if only to prove that writing on a schedule is harder than I thought...

...But mostly, 2007 was the year of collaboration, with the successful launch of A Pack A Day, the Cardboard Junkie/Baseball Card Blog alliance in creating The 792, and interactive projects like The Great Goudey Trade-away and Top Topps. Both proved to be unqualified successes thanks to Blog readers. And speaking of readers, 126,400 people visited The Blog (that's over 184,000 page views!), from all over the country and the world.

I got a lot of emails, answered a lot of questions, got some hate mail, made some friends, ate some bad food, went to some shows...

Not a bad year. Here's to another.



Fondly,


Ben



If I know anything about my audience, it's that they see right through the baseball card media's silence towards the recent, controversial book from Michael O'Keeffe and Teri Thompson. In case you aren't familiar with The Card, it tells the story behind the most famous card in the hobby: The former Gretzky/McNall T206 Piedmont Honus Wagner. It raises some interesting ideas, including that the card has been trimmed, that PSA had knowledge of it being trimmed, that Mastro's kind of a jerk, and many more fun little tidbits that makes this hobby great.

I've written my fair share about the book, including a lengthy interview with one of the book's authors. In case you want more coverage, head over to Gelf Magazine. Gelf will also be hosting O'Keeffe and Thompson as part of their Varsity Letters reading series this Wednesday in New York City.